That thinking has shaped the investment case for years. But is this still the right lens through which to view the business? Or does it risk underestimating how earnings actually respond to changes in rates and the economy over time?

More resilient to rates than many assume

The traditional view of Lloyds is fairly straightforward. Falling interest rates are expected to squeeze banking margins, reduce profitability and weaken returns. For a UK-focused lender with a large mortgage book, that has long been seen as a major risk.

But the latest results suggest the picture may now be more nuanced. In its first-quarter update, the group actually increased its net interest income guidance for 2026. Net interest margin also improved to 3.17%, while management said structural hedge income is now expected to rise to more than £8bn by 2027.

That structural hedge is important. Put simply, it allows the bank to lock in returns on deposits over time rather than being immediately exposed to every shift in interest rates. As a result, the impact of lower rates can feed through more gradually than many investors assume, helping smooth earnings across the cycle.

None of this means rates no longer matter. But it does suggest Lloyds may now be less immediately vulnerable to rate movements than the market’s traditional playbook implies.

A broader earnings model is emerging

The bank is increasingly trying to diversify its sources of income beyond traditional lending.

Alongside its core retail and mortgage business, it’s building exposure to areas such as wealth management, commercial services, payments and consumer propositions. These are still relatively small contributors, but they are designed to add more stable, fee-based earnings over time.

Alongside this, there’s a clear focus on efficiency. Ongoing cost discipline and simplification efforts are supporting improved operating leverage, with management continuing to target stronger cost-to-income outcomes as the strategy develops.

Taken together, the direction of travel is towards a more balanced earnings mix. That doesn’t remove sensitivity to the UK economy. But it does suggest returns may become less dependent on a single driver and more influenced by execution, product mix and capital allocation over time.

What’s the verdict?

There are still clear risks to consider. Despite efforts to diversify earnings, the group remains heavily exposed to the UK economy.

A sharper slowdown in growth, weaker housing activity or a deterioration in employment conditions would still feed through into lending volumes and credit quality over time.

There’s also ongoing uncertainty around motor finance-related costs, which continues to sit in the background.

However, the broader picture is more balanced than the traditional narrative suggests. Earnings are being supported by a combination of strong capital generation, improving efficiency and a structural hedge that smooths the impact of interest rate changes. That doesn’t remove cyclical exposure, but it does change how quickly it feeds through.

For investors, the key question is whether the market fully reflects that shift. On current evidence, Lloyds still looks more resilient than the classic ‘rate-sensitive UK bank’ label implies, which could make the shares worth considering for long-term investors.

The post Are investors still using an outdated playbook to value Lloyds shares? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

Can it continue rising though? If broker estimates are accurate, Lloyds’ shares will increase another 28% over the next 12 months. That’s based on the average of 18 different price forecasts today.

Not many expected the Black Horse Bank to take off as it has, myself included. But I feel its share price could be on the cusp of a sharp correction. And I’ve found 16,976 more reasons to be cautious right now.

Customer exodus

Lloyds is one of the most trusted names in UK banking. In a mature industry with limited growth potential, this is worth its weight in gold. It allows the business to generate significant profits and pay healthy dividends to its shareholders.

The problem is sector competition is fierce, putting established names like this under growing pressure. And the strain to keep customers and attract new ones is mounting, as building societies and challenger banks expand and improve their product ranges. This, in turn, poses a significant threat to Lloyds’ profits (and, by extension, share price).

Q1 data from the Current Account Switch Service (CASS) underlines the scale of the challenge. On the plus side, the number of people switching to Lloyds accounts outweighed those moving away by 12,073.

The problem is migration from the bank‘s subsidiaries more than offset these gains. Net outflows for Halifax and Bank of Scotland in Q1 were 25,629 and 3,420 respectively. The result? The broader Lloyds Banking Group lost a net 16,976 current account holders in the quarter.

Mounting dangers

These falling numbers create a variety of problems for banks. Cross-selling opportunities decline, and operators can be forced to seek other more expensive forms of funding (like issuing bonds). In response, they may have to offer switching incentives and better rates to attract customers, eroding margins.

The thing is, tough competition’s nothing new in the banking sector. And yet Lloyds remains one of the UK’s biggest players, with around 28m customers. So would this threat alone discourage me from buying its shares? Probably not.

However, competitive risks aren’t the only obstacle to Lloyds’ profits, both in the near term and beyond. Other major potential dangers include:

• Rising credit impairments as the UK economy cools.
• Weak loan demand from consumers and businesses.
• A housing market crash as interest rates rise.
• Soaring car finance misconduct costs.
• Falling interest rates further out that reduce net interest margins (NIMs).

Time to avoid Lloyds shares?

To be clear, Lloyds remains a solid, well-functioning bank. It has a good record of earnings growth — even in difficult times — and a robust balance sheet to invest in areas like products and its digital platform. Its strong CET1 capital ratio of 13.4% also bodes well for shareholders seeking more juicy dividends.

But in my view, the risks of holding Lloyds’ shares today far outweigh the potential benefits they might deliver. The bank might be worth consideration for less risk-averse investors. I’ll be buying other FTSE 100 shares for my portfolio though.

The post 16,976 more reasons why Lloyds share price could sink appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

Here’s the thing. Focusing on a single year is not how you should approach investing in the stock of a company. What we want to do instead is look at the longer term and the effects of dividend growth and share price appreciation that could push that yield into the 10% range or even higher. Let’s take a look at how, using an example stake of £5,000.

How much in dividends?

Five years ago, the dividend yield offered by Lloyds shares was 4.69%. On the surface, it sounds pretty similar to today’s yield, doesn’t it? Except there’s a key difference.

Lloyds has enjoyed a terrific few years. Earnings have grown, and so has the share price and the dividend offered. An investor picking up a 45p share in 2021 would be looking at a forecast dividend today of 3.65p – that’s a yield of 8.03%. Not bad, but we can go one better.

Let’s reinvest the dividends collected along the way. To simplify the calculation, I will assume the reinvestment from each year’s dividends happens in May. Putting it together, the dividend yield would now be 10.93% on the original stake.

That means the £5,000 stake invested then would be looking at a dividend return over the next 12 months of £547. I should mention the stake itself has grown a great deal during that time too – it would now be £12,845.

That sounds pretty good to me. But can the good times continue?

A buy?

It should be pointed out here that the above results come during what has been a very good time for Lloyds Bank. Had I selected a five-year period shortly after the 2008 recession then the numbers above would not have looked so rosy. And looking towards the future, there are risks to be aware of in the coming years too.

Chief among them, perhaps, is Lloyds’ focus on mortgages. As the nation’s largest mortgage lender, the sluggish rate of housebuilding in the country and persistently high mortgage borrowing costs could both pose problems.

And with around 95% of revenue coming within these shores, the stuttering UK economy may be a drag on the stock too. Rivals like Barclays in the US and HSBC in China are attached to much faster-growing economies.

A counterpoint to the above is that the biggest driver of Lloyds recent success – higher interest rates, which mean higher margins for banks – is looking set to stay high. I saw a 6% inflation target being mooted a few days ago too. That could be another reason rates are kept high and mean the next five years of dividends would be similar to the last five. I think the stock is worth a look.

The post £5,000 invested in Lloyds shares 5 years ago now pays dividends of… appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

The exceptional figures have been driven by stronger earnings, firmer margins and consistently robust credit performance across the bank. But forecast increases in its profits and a major gap between the share’s price and its value point to more to come.

So what sort of returns might investors be eyeing in the coming months and years?

What are the potential share price gains?

Discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis remains the clearest way to estimate where a stock ‘should’ trade, in my view. It does this by projecting future cash flows and translating them into today’s money.

Naturally, the less certain those forecasts are, the higher the return investors demand — and the heavier the discount becomes. Analysts’ DCF models differ, with some more bullish than mine and others more restrained.

But using my own assumptions — including an 8.3% discount rate — Lloyds screens as 47% undervalued at its current 97p price. That points to a fair value of £1.83 — nearly double the current price.

So if the stock continues drifting toward fair value over time, this could be a superb opportunity if those DCF assumptions hold.

Are dividend returns going up too?

Analysts expect Lloyds’ dividend yields to rise to 4.3%, 5.1%, and 5.4% respectively from this year to 2028. These sit comfortably above the present 3.1% average of the FTSE 100, although they could go down as well as up over time.

Using the forecast 5.4% return, a £20,000 holding in the bank would make £80,695 in dividends after 30 years — the end of the standard long-term investment cycle. By that point, the shares’ total value would be £100,695.

And this would generate a yearly income of £5,438 from dividends alone.

What’s going to drive shareholder gains?

Steady expansion in a company’s earnings underpins lasting gains in its share price and dividends. A risk to Lloyds is a slower UK economy that could soften demand for loans and financial products. Another is rising competition across its key mortgages, savings and digital banking divisions.

Nevertheless, analysts forecast its earnings will surge by an average 12.4% a year to end-2028 at minimum. Indeed, its Q1 2026 results released on 29 April saw profit before tax surge 33% year on year to £2bn.

Management also reiterated its key profitability target — return on tangible equity — of over 16% for the full year.

My investment view

The past two years have shown what Lloyds can deliver, with earnings, margins and credit quality all moving in the right direction. And the forecasts suggest that momentum is not finished yet.

The shares are still trading well below fair value on DCF measures, and dividends look set to rise. Meanwhile, analysts expect double‑digit earnings growth over the medium term at least.

I already hold two banking stocks — HSBC and NatWest — so adding another would unsettle the risk/reward balance of my portfolio. But for those without this conflict, Lloyds looks well-positioned to keep rewarding patient and savvy investors and is worth considering.

For me, other deeply undervalued, high-yielding stocks have recently caught my attention.

The post £20,000 invested in Lloyds shares 2 years ago is now worth… appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

For a FTSE 100 bank that many investors had written off as a dull, low-growth institution, these explosive returns paint quite a different picture. The question now is, will Lloyds’ shares double all over again?

Can the UK bank keep climbing?

Understanding why Lloyds has been on such a rampage isn’t hard. Higher interest rates have expanded net interest margins considerably, and Lloyds’ clever interest hedging strategies have amplified those gains. And even in 2026, this momentum’s expected to continue with net interest income on track to climb 9.6%, reaching £14.9bn, according to management’s upgraded forecast.

In fact, the bank’s fourth quarter results for 2025 significantly beat analyst expectations with earnings per share landing at 2.64p compared to the 2.03p that was projected by experts. And subsequently, share price forecasts have been getting hiked in response, with the most bullish price target reaching 130p.

Compared to where the stock’s trading today, this forecast indicates investors could earn a roughly 32% gain over the next 12 months. And that’s before factoring in any extra gains from dividends or buybacks.

In other words, it doesn’t look like the experts think Lloyds’ shares are going to double again soon. But there’s nonetheless still a compelling short- and long-term growth opportunity on offer if management continues to execute.

Sadly, this isn’t a risk-free venture. And there’s one looming threat that investors need to understand before considering Lloyds’ shares for their portfolio.

The motor finance cloud

In late March, the Financial Conduct Authority handed down its final ruling on the motor finance mis-selling scandal. And the industry was ordered to begin executing a sector-wide redress scheme worth an estimated £7.5bn in total, with average payouts of £830 per affected customer.

Lloyds, through its Black Horse motor finance arm, faces by far the largest exposure. It has already set aside a £1.95bn provision. More crucially, in April, it announced it would not challenge the FCA scheme, choosing to proceed with the compensation plan instead. The decision brings clarity, but also confirms that a significant chunk of cash is walking out the door.

The uncertainty isn’t entirely resolved either. Around 30,000 customers have taken separate High Court action against Lloyds seeking higher payouts than the FCA scheme offers, with a collective £66m claim lodged. And the FCA’s complaint pause lifts on 31 May, opening the floodgates to new claims.

So where does that leave investors today?

The bottom line

Like other institutional analysts, I’m sceptical that Lloyds’ shares will double again over the next 12 months, especially with the motor finance compensation cheques on the verge of being signed.

But over the longer term, I wouldn’t rule it out. Lloyds is still a highly cash generative business and could evolve into a robust defensive compounder for patient investors. So while it may not be a great fit for growth investors like myself, it could still be worth a closer look for those with a lower risk tolerance.

The post Could I double my money with Lloyds shares in 2026? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

Here are three reasons why.

1. War threats

The clearest risk today is an escalation in the Iran war, worsening inflationary risks and slowing economic growth. Both threaten to derail earnings across the banking sector by affecting loan growth and raising impairments.

Rising inflation would be especially bad for Lloyds, given its place as Britain’s biggest mortgage provider. Latest Halifax data showed average house prices fell 0.5% in March as buyer demand dried up. If interest rates increase, home sales could slump and more than offset the boost that rate hikes provide to banks’ margins.

The UK economy is especially sensitive to events in the Middle East, due to factors like its large services economy, high energy imports, and already weak momentum. It’s not difficult to see how a long war could be catastrophic for Lloyds’ share price.

2. More bad motor news?

Last month, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) came up with a final compensation figure for past car loan misconduct. The total cost to lenders? £9.1bn, some £2bn less than had previously been suggested.

But the saga is far from over, and the possibility of higher thumping costs lingers.

Last week, Barclays raised its own provisions for customer compensation. This is now £430m, an increase of £105m. Might Lloyds do the same in the coming weeks and months? It wouldn’t be the first time — provisions have been hiked twice already to current levels of £2bn.

That’s not all, as lenders face court battles from customers seeking higher payouts that what the FCA determined. With 12.1m cases of mis-sold motor finance being recorded, the final bill could be astronomical.

3. Horribly expensive

These aren’t the only major risks facing Lloyds in the near-term and beyond. Its customer base and pricing power is being steadily eroded by the rising influence of challenger banks. Savers are moving from traditional deposit accounts to interest-bearing ones, hitting margins. There’s also the threat of costs running out of control as broader inflationary pressures rise.

This all leads me to the third threat to Lloyds shares: its enormous valuation. Are all of these dangers baked into the current share price? I don’t think so.

At 97.8p per share, the bank’s price-to-book (P/B) ratio is 1.4, above the long-term average of 0.9. This also shows Lloyds’ share price trading at a larger premium to balance sheet assets than the broader banking sector. A high valuation such as this leaves the firm especially vulnerable to a price correction.

There’s a lot I like about Lloyds. Its resilience in what’s been a tough period for the UK economy, for instance, and how its cash-rich balance sheet supports strong dividends. But the risks are rising sharply, and I can’t help but fear for Lloyds’ shares in the coming months.

The post 3 reasons why Lloyds shares could sink in May! appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

The bank’s shares are now (2 May) changing hands for 15% less than they were at the start of the February. And analysts have a 12-month price target that’s over 20% higher. Could this be a buying opportunity to consider? Let’s see if the bank’s latest results provide any clues.

What’s the bottom line?

On Wednesday (29 April), Lloyds published its results for the first quarter of 2026. And what stood out to me was its earnings per share (EPS) of 2.4p. This was 0.2p better than for the previous quarter and a 0.7p improvement on a year earlier.

Importantly, it was 0.3p above analysts’ expectations. Before the results were released, they were anticipating EPS for the full year of 9.9p. I wonder if their forecasts will now be upgraded?

Some of the earnings improvement can be explained by a reduction in the number of shares in issue, brought about by the bank’s huge share repurchase programme. But the bank’s also been working hard to reduce its overheads. During the quarter, its cost/income ratio was 52.7%. For 2025, it was 58.6%.

In the first quarter of 2026, the Group delivered sustained strength in financial performance, growing our income, maintaining our cost discipline and delivering strong profitability. Our differentiated business model remains resilient in the context of the current economic uncertainties.

Charlie Nunn, Group Chief Executive, Lloyds Banking Group

Undervalued?

When it comes to assessing valuations, EPS is a key metric. At the moment, Lloyds’ shares are changing hands for around 10 times forecast 2026 earnings. Generally speaking, retail banks trade on a multiple of nine, so this isn’t too far out of kilter.

Looking ahead to 2028, analysts are predicting EPS of 13.7p. With a forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of just over 7, the bank’s shares appear cheap. On this basis, I can see why analysts’ consensus is that they’re worth 120p. At this level, the bank has a forward (2028) P/E ratio of 8.8. This seems very reasonable to me.

But…

However, despite this week’s impressive results, these forecasts seem like a bit of a stretch. Although there’s much to admire about the bank — including its brand and its management team — virtually all of its income is earned in the UK.

Here, growth forecasts have recently been downgraded by both the OECD and International Monetary Fund. Unemployment’s rising and inflation’s starting to pick up again. Also, business confidence is low, which is holding back investment.

I don’t wish to sound negative but I think this is a fair assessment of the state of the domestic economy. Against this backdrop, surely Lloyds can’t double its EPS over the next three years, as analysts are predicting?

That’s why, in my opinion, there are more exciting opportunities to consider elsewhere. Indeed, there are loads of high-quality, rapidly-growing UK companies that generate the majority of their earnings overseas. I believe these are worthy of further investigation.

The post Analysts reckon the Lloyds share price should be 21% higher! appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

Doing the maths

Let’s start with the numbers. The stock’s current dividend yield is 3.75%. So if someone wanted to make £6,000 from income over the course of the year, an investor would need to have £160k worth of Lloyds’ stock.

That’s assuming someone invested right now. Going forward, if the dividend per share increases, the amount made from holding the stock could also increase. For example, over the past year, the total dividend paid is 3.65p. This was a bump up from the 3.17p in the previous year, which was also higher than the 2.76p from the year prior.

There’s clearly a trend here. So over time, the person may be able to reduce the total amount of shares needed to be owned in order to generate an average of £500 a month.

The fundamental picture

Aside from the pure numbers, the other point that needs to be addressed is whether the outlook makes sense for the bank to do well. After all, if things go wrong for Lloyds, a dividend cut could prevent the investor from reaching their goal.

From my perspective, the outlook for sustainable dividends is positive. The bank’s benefiting from a higher-for-longer interest rate environment, aided by the likely increase in inflation this year. That might not be great news for borrowers, but it’s good for lenders like Lloyds. In fact, Q1 results from earlier this week showed a 9% jump in net income. This was driven by stronger lending income and an improving net interest margin.

The other reason why I like the bank is that it doesn’t rely on flashy investment banking revenues or risky international exposure. It’s a UK-focused, bread-and-butter lender. As long as the UK economy holds up reasonably well, the bank can continue to churn out solid earnings with strong cash flow. That ultimately translates to growing dividends.

Other alternatives

The bank does have risks, such as the ongoing saga with the car finance scandal. The reputational (and financial) damages still could increase, and so it needs to be monitored closely.

Yet even from the income angle, some might want to target divdiend shares with a higher yield. For example, 11 stocks in the FTSE 250 have yields above 9%.

To hopefully achieve a £500 monthly average payment, the total needed for a 9% yield would be £66.66k. This is much lower than the £150k for Lloyds, but it does have a potentially higher risk.

Yet it serves as a good point to show that even though I believe Lloyds is a good income share for investors to consider, there are plenty of other options out there that might be more suitable for people, depending on their risk tolerance.

The post How much do you need in Lloyds shares to make £500 in monthly passive income? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

I’ll start by suggesting what they shouldn’t do. And that’s panic-sell. Top FTSE 100 stocks like this one go up and down all the time. Short-term volatility is nothing to worry about. It’s the price we pay for the big returns equities typically deliver in the longer run. Unless somebody needs their money in the immediate future, they should keep calm and carry on. So here’s a question I do think is worth considering. Should investors think about buying more?

Actually, I’d argue that’s a pretty simple question too. I believe Lloyds is a terrific stock for investors seeking an all-round combination of dividend income and share price growth. With a long-term view, it’s always a pretty good time to consider Lloyds, in my opinion. Over five, 10 years or even longer, I would expect it to deliver. Of course, there are no guarantees with any stock. And there will always be ups and downs along the way.

How big an opportunity is this?

So how excited should investors be today? Now that’s a trickier question. Right now, global markets are on a knife edge. On Thursday (30 April), the oil price hit $124, having doubled since the Iran war started on 28 February. That will drive up inflation and interest rates, and squeeze the UK economy. That could hit demand for mortgages at Lloyds subsidiary Halifax, the giant mortgage lender. It could ultimately drive up bad debts too.

Oil has since retreated to $108 doubles but shortages remain a live risk. The stock market could still crash. If it did, Lloyds would surely follow, and get cheaper.

So should investors wait? I can see the temptation, but there’s an issue here. Second-guessing market movements is next to impossible. If Iran tensions ease, we could see the mother of all relief rallies. In that scenario, investors will have missed their opportunity. As a rule, anybody who hangs around waiting for the bottom of the market, usually misses it by mile.

Also, there are solid reasons for considering Lloyds today. Higher projected interest rates could boost its profitability, by allowing it to widen the gap between what it pays savers and charges borrowers. These are called net interest margins. It’s a key banking profitability metric.

Lloyds already looks good value, with a forward price-to-earnings ratio of just 9.88 for 2026. That’s marginally below its average 10-year P/E of 10.5.

Would you risk calling this market?

However, I shouldn’t overstate the scale of its recent share price dip. The share price is still up 37% over the last year, and 111% over five years. This isn’t exactly a beaten-down stock opportunity.

That strong share price growth has squeezed the yield. The shares are forecast to yield 4.6% in 2026, which is good. But it’s well below the 10-year average forward yield of 5.8%.

So here’s my view. At below £1, Lloyds is well worth considering. Absolutely. Investors could hang on, and hope to bag it at an even cheaper price. That’s their call. It might work, it might not. Either way, it looks compelling today.

The post Lloyds shares plunge below £1 – does that make them a screaming buy? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.

The actual results show a solid performance to start the 2026 year. But one broker, at least, isn’t impressed. Shore Capital has Lloyds as a Sell, on the basis that the latest results were already baked into the share price — implying there’s little room for safety.

So what did the quarter actually look like? Highlights include…

• Statutory profit before tax up 33% year on year
• Underlying net interest income up 8%
• Operating costs reduced by 3%

But one thing Shore points out is that the Lloyds share price is around 1.7 times tangible net asset value, which it sees as too high. So should I dump my Lloyds shares? I don’t feel any urgent need to hit the Sell button, but we do need to dig a bit deeper.

Short-term targets

I’m sympathetic to a potential asset-related overvaluation. And with Lloyds so heavily into the UK’s mortgage market, I think that might weigh on sentiment. Especially as the latest expected round of inflation and economic squeeze could put more pressure on asset values.

But even Shore’s bearish Lloyds share price target helps to reassure me a little. It’s at 91p, and only 6% below the price at the time of writing. If I sold shares every time I thought they might be 6% overvalued, and bought when they looked 6% undervalued… I’d quickly spend all my money on trading fees.

I want to think beyond the latest numbers themselves — which are just a short-term snapshot, at a confusing time for economic and company outlooks. And I’m struck by something CEO Charlie Nunn said…

Our differentiated business model remains resilient in the context of the current economic uncertainties. We remain focused on supporting UK households and businesses as they look to strengthen their financial positions and achieve their goals.

Trust in the UK?

Buying Lloyds shares is very much an investment in the UK itself. And it does come without the direct global worries that afflict other banks — though in addition to not enjoying their international opportunities. So an obvious question for potential investors arises in my mind: do you have confidence in the long-term future of British businesses?

My personal answer is yes. Otherwise, how could the UK stock market have so soundly beaten other forms of investment for well over a century?

Inflation and interest rates are indeed threats for Lloyds. And valuation concerns in the light of current uncertainties are real ones. Valuation fears — after a 113% rise over five years — could alone mean a further weak spell for the Lloyds share price.

But I’m holding. And I don’t think investors should write off considering Lloyds shares — though waiting another few months for more clarity might help.

The post As the Lloyds share price falls while profits rise, is it time to dump? appeared first on The Twelfth Magpie.